Denver Broncos blog, news and rumors


FB

[hype it up!]
[Share with Yardbarker]

Published on 06/18/2009 at Thu Jun 18 12:58.
Tagged: ,,,,.



Jay Cutler launches a pass to Brandon Marshall.  (Joe Mahoney/RMN Photo)

Jay Cutler launches a pass to Brandon Marshall. The Broncos might lose both players now that Marshall has asked for a trade. (Joe Mahoney/RMN Photo)

No matter your opinion of Jay Cutler and his exodus from Mile High Country, you’ll never convince me that the situation couldn’t have been handled better. Now, the Broncos have the opportunity to do just that.

Here we sit, three months later, and Josh McDaniels and Pat Bowlen are facing a similar situation with another young Pro Bowler, Brandon Marshall. Marshall has asked to be traded. Marshall has said his goodbye to the fans.

You know what I say? Let him talk. Keep #15 in Denver.

If you take McDaniels’ comments at face value, it appears the Broncos intend to do just that. “(We) are going to continue our dialogue with Brandon and his representative,” McDaniels told the Associated Press. “We look forward to having Brandon at training camp.”

This is the only resolution that comes with a happy ending in my mind. Trading Marshall comes with too much collateral damage – not only will it be hard to get equal value with draft picks, but trading two pouty Pro Bowlers at their behest sends the wrong message to the team. Don’t let the tail wag the dog, McD. Take control.

We all know the contractual situation with Marshall is complicated. There’s no doubt that, on the field, Marshall has earned a fat new contract. Off the field, however, Marshall carries too much risk, both legally and medically. So the Broncos need to call his bluff, let him sit out as much training camp as he dares, and start contract negotiations when they’re good and ready. With the upcoming CBA situation, Marshall would only be a restricted free agent in 2010, giving the Broncos all the time and leverage they need.

That’s how they handled the Casey Wiegmann situation, and I applaud them for it. McDaniels even waxed poetic at Wiegmann’s cooperation in the entire process in the team’s press release, saying “The professionalism and leadership (Wiegmann) showed throughout this process was outstanding.”

That quote raised my eyebrows — do you know how often I can recall a coach’s quote being included in a press release covering something as simple as a contract extension? Never, not once, zero. That was a message to Marshall and the team, plain and simple: play by our rules, and we’ll take care of you.

I love it. McD screwed the pooch with Cutler in my opinion, but he’s saying and doing the right things with Marshall. Here’s hoping he can put his money where his mouth is.

  • kerry

    McDaniels said the same thing about “talking to Cutler” and ultimately he was traded. no reason to believe a single word McDaniels says. he is a bold faced liar and will trade Marshall the second the opportunity presents itself.

  • http://BroncoTalk.net Mr.East

    Kerry,

    That’s such bs. I forgot that you worked for the front office of Denver. Who/What exactly do you back? It seems like every time something happens you manage to slam every side of it.

  • kerry

    i sure as hell dont back McDaniels. that much i can tell you. he hasnt shown ANYTHING worth backing. and i dont have to work for the Broncos to see that MCDaniels is a god damn fraud.

  • http://BroncoTalk.net Mr.East

    Kerry,

    You would slam Jesus if he was the head coach.

  • kerry

    i dont believe in jesus. so no i wouldnt.

  • http://ttmt.com T-Money

    so much anger

  • merc22

    i hate whoever this kerry guy is, he sounds like he is in his 30s+ and is living in the past with elway. Its a new era, stuff gets handled differently now

  • http://broncomadness.com Garrett Barnes

    ok, i back mcdaniels until we play a game. mcdaniels we can only put our full trust in, until we actually see him coach a game. then its open season on him. that’s just my opinion on mcdaniels. remember guys, shanahan was a crappy g.m in situations too and he stayed here 14 years!

    as for this, i totally agree kyle. i especially like what you said about the message he was sending. when you work for a business and you want a raise, you work your hardest and show more effort, not do the exact opposite. the nfl is a business isn’t it?

    show professionalism and act like a man and you will get what you want. plain and simple.

  • kerry

    nope only 27.

  • http://broncomadness.com Garrett Barnes

    guys, i’m just saying, keep it a football conversation not a bashing kerry conversation. there really is no point of it. he is going to go on with his “antagonistic” opinions (the light way of describing them) no matter what we all say or do.

  • kerry

    Garrett:

    they can bash me all they want. i dont care. its actually quite funny because instead of posting something to refute me claims, they just lash out with infantile remarks. its truely funny. people love to hate me.

  • Thomas

    I’ve been reading this blog long enough to know not to ever argue with Kerry haha!

    But any way, I completely agree with you Kyle, I really hope McDaniels learned from his mistakes with Cutler and will sort everything out with this whole B Marsh mess. Losing B Marsh could definitely ruin our season, I couldn’t really see any trades being worth while for us.

  • CJ

    I dont care what kerry says Merc’s comment was Hilarious!

    anyways i think that you cant force a quarterback to play for you but you can make a receiver. Brandon Marshall will end up being fined 50,000 dollars and go back to camp go to the press and say hes proud to be a denver bronco.

    But remember we did sign Brandon Loyd on monday. A possible replacement?

  • Andpark

    Best I think we all can do is give credit to McD handling this a lot better than the Cutler situation and just let the coach coach his first game and see what happens. All this bashing and taking sides doesn’t do much but get us all yelling at each other.

    Marshall is a great player, we need him next year. If he gets traded it puts our offense at a serious disadvantage. If McD thinks Marshall isn’t worth all these headaches and can actually get something for him then I have to give McD credit that he has some sort of plan.

    Aug 14 is the first preseason game, let’s see what wonder kid can do.

  • Dean

    What’s wrong with arguments? It’s June, whats else can we talk about? Basketball, hockey are done. Baseball hasn’t reached the all star break. Isn’t this a place to discuss, be it praise or to critic our beloved Broncos? Good post Kyle. I agree with you that McDaniels screwed the pooch with Cutler and hope he can fix this situation with B-Marsh. In my 20+ years of following the Broncos i’ve only have to endure 4 losing seasons, 90′, 94′, 99, and 07′ and I better not see another one this year.

  • (stuck in) raiderland

    Whatever happens with B-Marsh, I just hope that the zany off-season is a once-in-a-decade occurrence. I can’t stand that we have had a bigger soap opera than the hated Raiders these past few months.

  • (stuck in) raiderland

    Also, I heard another trade rumor: word has it that Kerry is holding out to be traded to the Raiders’ fan site. Any confirmation on that?

  • Joe H.

    Trade Kerry for cash!!!

  • Anthony

    Kerry:
    Explain to me how this is McDaniels fault. You have absolutely no arguments that back up your claim. Why is this so surprising, you can see this coming from a mile away that BMarsh would ask for a new contract.

    Reason #1 – New QB so he believes his stats will be hurt by that.
    Reason #2 – Uncapped year next year which will extend his contract another 2 years at a very low rate.
    Reason #3 – He deserves it based on his play in the past two seasons.
    Reason #4 – Many other wide receivers have tried the same thing (Boldin, B. Edwards, Chad Johnson) so BMarsh figures why shouldn’t I try the same.
    Reason #5 – he has a court date coming up in the next few months and if convicted he could face another suspension from Roger Goodell.

    There I gave you 5 good reasons as to why Brandon Marshall would ask for a trade and none of them have to do with Josh McDaniels. So let’s see you come up with an educated rebuttle, or do you need a dictionary to find out what that word means. Your argument that this is Josh McDaniels fault has no merit to it whatsoever.

  • mr. me

    kerry, and all other dudes, this is a football site, try 2 keep your opinions of politics, faith, and other stuff out of it ok
    and watch the profanity!

  • Shawn

    I like the Broncos

  • rcsodak

    Anthony, good points! Doubt he’ll answer you, though.

    Joe H……I suggest we start at $1.
    We can always work our way down. :)

  • milehighs

    Kerry

    You sound just like me.YOU TOLD ME THAT I WAS BLANK BLANK BLANK all kinds of bad words.Now your word sound like mine.

    Broncos may as well trade Brandon.We lost tomarrows hall of fame qb. any ways.May as well trade Brandon to.Hell trade the hole Broncos franchise to New Mexico.Albuquerque Broncos!!!!!!!

  • milehighs

    I wish icould fire the idiots that got rid of Cutler and fixing to get rid of Broandon.What a joke i dont belive whats going on.Someone pinch me.Wake me up from this nightmare.

    STRIKE,STRIKE,STRIKE.Its not the Denver Broncos no more.Its the Mc Bolen team noe,and it realy sucks.Move over Lions here come the Denver Mc. Bolens team.

  • broncoNM

    I agree that we probably wouldnt get fair value at this point. I hope the FO is listening to offers tho. I would be willing to ship off Marshall for the right price. If i was a betting man i would say marshall will stay which i dont mind because he will be valuable for orton (big physical target with good ability to gain YAC). This is a good situation. We can listen to offers but we dont have to move him. It cleveland offers B. Edwards and a pick or Ravens offer a slew of draft picks we take it!… If not we hold on to him. As stated i doubt any team offers much for him… so he will probably stay.

  • roshon2411

    Anthony,

    You’re probably right, Marshall would have most likely asked for a new contract no matter what, weather it be McD, Shanny, or someone else as coach. But reason #1 could and most likely be blamed on McDaniels. If Shanny was here Cutler would still be the QB. Same would go if any of the other candidates were hired. I do think McDaniels could be to blame for Marshall seeking a trade though. It’s all speculative at this point but maybe, Marshall sees a sinking ship with some of the mistakes McDaniels has made in his first few months and thats not my opinion, even Bowlen admits hes made mistakes. I just think it’s a little easier to ask for a trade when the coach is a 33 year old inexperienced, first time Head Coach than if it was a tenured SB winning coach like Shanny. I do think if McDaniels really wants Marshall then he’ll stay, if he doesn’t then he’s gone.

  • MikeY55

    maybe rod smith will talk to him and tell him mile high is where its attt! I just wish there were some more articles on what was going on in the camp i’ve read a few on some other sites but i prefer to hear it here.. one site said they think chris baker will be the starting nose tackle this season… so i’m a lil skeptical on if he knows what hes talking about fully even though he has talent i don’t see him starting the season as the #1 nose

  • Rob Bronco

    Even though this will never happen, I say the Broncos trade Marshall for a 1st and a 3rd next year. I realize that he’s worth more than that, but the Broncos would then have 2 first round picks (again) and they can use one of them to draft a Heisman Trophy winner (Tebow or Bradford) or candidate (McCoy) and build this team the way it’s supposed to be built. They drafted a strong, powerful running back this year. They picked up some speed in the secondary, they’ve locked up their center and left tackle, and they’ll have a year of the 3-4 defense under their belts. Not to mention that McDaniels will have a year to plan for the QB of the future.

  • steve-o

    yea, but dont most good teams have a #1 receiver?? by letting go of the beast we’re inhibiting royal’s development..

  • jcampb72

    http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-network-total-access/09000d5d810e4d5c/Broncos-report

    The broncos need Brandon period. If we lose him 5-11 is as good as it gets. And we won’t even have that top 10 draft pick. Man, tough times in Denverland.

  • Shelly

    Personally, I think that McDummy sucks as head coach. You get rid of your quaterback as soon as he hits a high point in his career and you think you’re doing agood job? How bout NO! Granted Cutler did piss me off by asking for the trade but his actions werw justified in the fact that he was not happy with McDummy and the lies he kept spewing out of his mouth. Now he thinks that he can do a better job with trying to keep Brandon and all I have to say is we all know that it’s a big loss to lose Cutler but then to lose Brandon on top of that will be just like giving the division title to everyone else in the AFCW. McDummy better handle himself the right way in this situation or he’s gonna be leading a broken team with low morale come the first game.

  • http://broncotalk.net (dee)

    I’d let him sit, with all the cases he’s catching he won’t be able to afford to sit out much long.

    As for Kerry, I’ve kinda become ammune to the negitivity, it use to be funny, now its just redundant, its hard to believe he’s actually a fan sometimes considering how much of the Broncos players/staff he hates. Nothing personal Kerry, its just the vibe you project.

  • mr. me

    hey Shawn, (comment#22)
    no really? thats weird even tho this is a broncos site? lol wow dude u just wanted 2 comment some’n?

  • jvill

    What a second. What’s wrong with being 30+?

    By the time you guys get to that age you’ll hopefully learn to ignore all the naysayers and complainers, and that engaging with them is a waste of time (although sometimes entertaining).

    The naysayers and complainers will always be there in any situation that has risk or gray areas. Just human nature.

  • Thomas

    I don’t mind Kerry I like his perspective on things. Sometimes he seems negative but in reality he is right most of the time, even if he can be harsh.

  • http://BroncoTalk.net Mr.East

    I agree with Shawn.

    Kerry… touche.

  • http://cdn0.sbnation.com/profile_images/111140/La_La_Mascot.jpg WhidbeyBronco

    East, you left the ‘space M’ out of your personal note to Kerry…

    Kyle, good post. If coach doesn’t want to ride the beef for screwing the pooch AGAIN then it’s in his power to fix this! Very simply! Pay him what he’s easily worth and protect our investment with behavior stipulations. If he still wants out then maybe it IS Mcd that’s the problem…

  • http://bandit Dan Myers

    Guys kerry is a TROLL, do not feed the trolls.

    Those who say that Jay and Brandon are the same situation for Josh are completely wrong. Jay (a QB) said he would not play for Josh. An unhappy starting QB is the worst. Even if he sits, he would be the biggest distraction. Denver had two courses ONLY, suspend or trade Jay. Bowlen made the right decision.
    Brandon has NO leverage, plus WR’s are much easier to develop then QB’s. And Wiegmann learned also.

    I love when everyone blames the coach for all these problems. Like the organization (Bowlen, Xanders, Ellis) are not going to be involved with the ‘what do we do’ discussion? DA I DON’T THINK SO.

  • http://bandit Dan Myers

    I forgot one major issue for those who say just pay him.
    Lets say that the Broncos give Brandon a 5 yr $50 million $10 million guarenteed contract with hooks for any disgressions, like pay back money, OK?
    So he gets suspended like we ALL know he will soon or later or released due to the disgressions. Yes the Broncos will get back some of the bonus money BUT the remaining ANNUAL $10 million SALARY will still go against the Broncos salary cap UNTIL the end of the 5 year contract. End of story.
    The ONLY way to get around the ‘dead money’ issue is to sign your players to ONE YEAR CONTRACTS. And yes it is allowed by the NFLPA but No player can get security with one year contracts.

  • ChuckD

    Orton needs Marshall. Orton doesn’t possess the strongest arm in the world so he needs a big receiver who can catch short passes and turn them into big gains. Obviously I hope Marshall would learn to secure the ball but you have to admit the guy has nutty skillz once the ball is in his hands. It’s amazing how hard that guy is to bring down.

  • ChuckD

    Also, is signing B-Marsh to a new contract a gamble…Yes but what signing in the NFL is not a gamble. We could all name off a grip of signings that didnt work out (T Henry would be a good starter) On the flip side because of all his baggage we’ll be able to sign him for less than a receiver of his caliber would normally get. As long as we can verify his health I would love to see B-Marsh back.

  • http://broncotalk.net (dee)

    Nice points Dan,

    I know all too well the dangers of the salary cap. My madden 09 franchise Broncos teams was ruined due to my lavish salary cap spending on high priced free agents who I later had to cut/trade due to lack of productivity.

    I did win 3 superbowls in a 5 year span though, until I had to totally rebuild. =D

  • http://cdn0.sbnation.com/profile_images/111140/La_La_Mascot.jpg WhidbeyBronco

    merc22 … clearly unclear as to the meaning of the term!

    meanwhile #$%%$# knock that crap off, we’re talking football here!

  • roshon2411

    This team is going to have to spend money sometime.

  • Rob Bronco

    Greatness isn’t always measured in the number of catches a receiver makes. Just because Marshall has 2 100+ reception seasons doesn’t make him our “star” receiver. He hardly played last year! Greatness is catching the ball when you MUST catch the ball. Ask the Steelers if they think Hines Ward is the tallest or fastest guy on the field. The Chargers had the #2 offense in football last season without a star receiver.

    Just ask the Cowboys, Eagles, and Bengals how a “star”receiver helped their teams.

  • roshon2411

    Ask the Steelers, Giants, Colts, and Patriots how “star” receivers help get them and win a Super Bowl. Don’t take this comment out of context either. I’m not saying BMarsh is going to lead us to the Super Bowl but Super Bowl teams have stars at every postion. How many WR’s will it take to find his replacement. I don’t want to go through bums like Patrick Jeffers, Marcus Nash, Chris Cole, Chad Plummer, Travis McGriff, Leroy Fields, Muneer Moore, Kevin Kasper, Ashley Lelie, Herb Haygood, Adrian Madise, Triandos Luke, Darius Watts, Domenik Hixon. And those are just the WR picks back to 96′ You can go back farther. Shanny struck gold with his picks of Marshall and Royal and I was hoping to see them team up for years the way Rod Smith and Eddie Mc did.

  • MeOMy

    I really don’t understand why people are down on the Broncos this year. So far the only starter they have lost on Offense is their QB. Granted Cutler has way more potential than Orton, but last year’s team was very undisciplined on offence. They could move the ball at times but could not score.

    Under McDaniels the offense will be much more disciplined. Not to mention the potential to finally have a legit RB will help out tremendously! Yes I know we still only have Orton. He doesn’t have the skills Cutler has but then again he also has never worked with the talent he has here, or the coach! With all this I don’t see how our offence will not be better than last years. Orton’s numbers are not that far behind Cutlers. Would it have been a lot better with Cutler? Yes, but even with Orton it is still going to be better.

    As for the defense, I don’t see how that hasn’t improved? Did we pick up great linemen? No, but they are a huge improvement over what we had last year. Not to mention we actually have S’s this year. While I’m a little concerned about our LB’s we really haven’t lost anyone there. D.J. is solid, Woodyard will only improve with a 2nd year, and Webster is returning. The other positive on defense is we actually have a coach that knows what they are doing on D.

    The only thing that I don’t see as improving this year is the schedule, which means we go 8-8 again. Not great, but good for a rebuilding team.

  • AtomicLeo

    MeOMy —

    Since you asked, I’ll tell you why I’m down on the Broncos. n order of importance IMO (notice McD didn’t make the top 3)

    (1) Schedule. The schedule is killer after week 4. It is entirely possible we could be looking at 4-5 losing game streak in October and November. The ONLY team we play after week 4 ’til Turkey Day that hasn’t been either a SB winner or a playoff team in the past two years is Washington and that’s a road game. I’d argue that our schedule is actually much worse than the Steeler’s schedule in 2008 and we have much less talent than the 2008 Steelers. The schedule is a huge problem.

    (2) Moving to a 3-4 defense without a well-defined player for NT. In a 3-4, the NT is just as important as the LT and QB on offense. If you watched the Chargers last year, their NT struggled. Much was made of Merriman, but the problems started at the NT position. Without a good NT, a 3-4 scheme is VERY soft up the middle and the LB can’t get to the QB. We play in a division with outstanding talent at the RB position even on a crappy teams like the Raiders. If we are soft up the middle……whooo boy….did you watch the Packers last year?

    (3) SD offense made a big leap last year on offense without their best player. I. Hate. Rivers. I personally will do a dance if he is ever permanently carted off the field after a wicked hit, but I will give him this: He carried the offense last year with little or no help from LT. He should have gone to the Pro-Bowl. Too bad the voting ended after Week 11 (or is it 12 not sure). Anyway, the Chargers have been a one-man show with an excellent defense. If Rivers continues to put up numbers like he did last year, they are going to run away with the division title by November. In the AFC, you have to win your division. The competition is too tough to count on a wild card spot, just ask the 11-5 Patriots. If Rivers has hit his stride and the front office in SD continues to select excellent/good defensive players, it will be very difficult for the Broncos to challenge SD in the next 2-3 years (barring some freak injury).

    (4) Moving to a 3-4 defense with an average LB core. I’ gonna disagree with you here when it comes to the LBs in Denver. DJ needs to be on the outside; he’s just not mentally quick enough to be a middle LB. The guy we brought in for middle LB has been with the Browns his entire career and hasn’t exactly lit-up the league. In fact I saw one profile on him that said he was only a 2-down kind of LB since he was so slow. Not what we need. I believe the root cause of the defense disaster last year actually started 3 seasons ago when Shanny neglected to draft good LBs and started plugging in walk-on FA into the LB positions. We had an excellent core during the late 90’s and pretty good 2000-2004, then it just started falling apart and the rest of the defense went with it.

    (4) New Coach. New Schemes on both sides of the ball. Even if McD had not dumped Cutler, the NE offense is complicated. The WRs make a ton of of adjustments at the line. The RB’s don’t just take a hand off and run. They are a big part of the passing game. It’s a big change from the west-coast-zone blocking the Broncos have run for 14 years. Any new overhaul like this needs time to gel and time to get the players.

    (5) Lack of talent. IMO the keys in order of importance to a successful NFL team are: Talent, Coaching, Scheme and Luck. And I don’t want to hear how NE took a bunch of no-name players and became a dynasty. Brady is a fantastic QB. Vrabel is an outstanding LB. Patriots have been very smart with player selection. Drafting talented guys that fit the program and getting rid of guys who they knew were at the end of their ‘usefulness’. Don’t kid yourself thinking that NE is a bunch backups. They a very talented football team. I bet Cassell does very well in KC this year. Scan over the Broncos roster and ask yourself: “Which of these guys could start on ANY team in the NFL?” Answer: Darn, few. Clady, DJ (maybe), Champ (if he’s healthy), Hillis, Royal, our RT (whose name I can’t think of right now!)….. Any one else? Do the same thing with the Steelers, Patriots and SD and I bet you can come up with 10-12 players. That’s why those teams are in the playoff hunt and we are not. Shanny excellent coaching covered up a lot of warts on the roster.

    I could go on but I think you get the picture….. 8-8 would be a best case scenario. I bet we go 2-4 in the division this year. Swept by SD, split with KC and the Radiers. I think KC is going to be MUCH better with Cassell and Haley. Edwards was an idiot and they basically had a ham sandwich at QB last year. That leaves CIN, CLE, DAL, NE, BAL, PIT, WAS, NYG, IND and PHI. I just don’t see 6 wins here. Assuming that If I’m right about the Broncos D-line that’ll be soft of the middle, we’re gonna struggle with any team that has a physical O-Line and/or a physical power RB (DAL, BAL, PIT, NYG). We *should* beat CIN and CLE, but I have a bad feeling about that CIN game. Maybe we catch DAL on a bad night. Doubt it. WAS is a possible W. Maybe PHI is resting starters late in the season and we pick up a cheapie W in late December.

    It looks like a whole lotta losses and 4-12 or 5-11 season. I’d be thrilled with 6+ wins.

  • Shawn

    mr. me, (comment 33) yup. just wanted to post. Simplicity seemed best to me at the time. I said all that really matters.

  • http://broncotalk.net Dman

    AtomicLeo Amen brother now we have someone talking with some sense here. You nailed it right on the head.